SPEED OF SOUND IN THIN METAL RODS AND YOUNG MODULUS

If you are interested, visit Introduction to Newtonian Mechanics with Java Applet Simulated Experiments.

      Introduction

      The measurements of sound velocity in metals are usually done for thin rods. They can also be performed for thin pipes of any constant cross-sectional shape. Rods are better, of course, because they can acquire more sound energy for the same size and result in long duration of the sound wave.
      Such rods or pipes must have a support which makes possible the creation of a single frequency standing wave. If a single support is applied right in the middle, a longest lasting will be standing wave with a fundamental frequency (first harmonic) . This wave has a node in the middle and two antinodes on the both ends of the rod or pipe. Oscillations of both ends of the rod can be easily detected with the tip of your finger. When two supports are arranged at one quarter and three quarters of the rod (pipe) length, good conditions for a lasting second harmonic is created. This standing wave has two nodes over the two supports and three antinodes. Two of them on the both ends and third in the middle. Therefore a wavelength     for the first harmonic is equal to the double length of the rod (pipe), and for the second harmonic is equal to the length of the rod (pipe). Similarly we can create good conditions for a third harmonic placing two supports at one sixth and five sixth of the rod length.
      If somehow we would be able to measure the frequencies  f  of these harmonics, then the speed of sound  c can be calculated from the formula

c  =     f .

Moreover, we also would be able to calculate Young modulus  Y  for the rod (pipe) material using the theoretical formula which relates the speed of sound to the Young modulus and the density  of the material

c  =  [ Y /  ] ½   .

This relation resembles very much the relation for velocity of transverse waves in a string. If the Young modulus is replaced by tension in the string and the ordinary density by a linear density of the string, then the mentioned relation for transverse waves in the string is recovered.
      The fact that speed of sound in metals and other solids must be dependent on their Young module can be easily justified. As a standing sound wave resides in a thin solid rod this rod undergoes a tiny mechanical vibrations that can be tested with the tip of your finger. In other words the rod elongates and shrinks periodically under a pressure exerted by the wave. But Young modulus relates pressures to elongations of the rod.

     Experimental

      A simple setup for standing waves frequency measurements is shown in Fig. 1. Striking the rod at the impact end we deliver there some mechanical energy with a wide range of frequencies. Some of these frequencies are resonance frequencies for the rod and they persist there longer in the form of  standing waves. The related vibrations of the rod ends are creating sound waves of the same frequency in the surrounding air. These waves are picked up by the microphone where an oscillating voltage of the same frequency is produced.  After amplification this voltage is sent to the oscilloscope or frequency meter. A moment after the rod is struck a sinusoidal signal related to the most persistent standing wave will be established on the oscilloscope screen (see Fig. 2). Counting number of half periods of this signal across the oscilloscope screen and a total time they occupy there, we can estimate the signal period T  (see Fig. 2). Its inverse is the frequency of the signal. The measurements of frequency with help of oscilloscope are interesting because they are showing time evolution of different standing waves established right after the rod impact (for more details see the article by M.T.Frank and E.Kluk , Phys.Teach. 29, 246 (1991)), but their accuracy is not very impressive.

   

Fig. 1.   Experimental setup

Fig. 2.  Frequency measurements

      More accurate frequency measurements can be made using digital electric multimeters with a frequency function. Some of them are not expensive with prices in the range of $50.00 - $90.00. The results of the frequency measurements with such multimeter (DMR-2208 by EMCO ~$60.00) as well as the calculated speeds of sound and Young module are shown in the table below.

Measurements and calculations results

 

Steel

Steel

Aluminum

Brass

Length [m]

1.004

0.916

0.856

0.890

Cross Section

1.91cm x 1.91 cm

diam. 1.27 cm

diam. 1.91 cm

diam 0.63 cm

Mass [kg]

2.860

0.910

0.681

0.2395

Density [kg/m3]

7840

7840

2780

8630

1st harmonic [Hz]

2580

2830

3030

 
2nd harmonic [Hz]

5160

5670

6060

4040

3rd harmonic [Hz]

7730

8500

9080

6070

Sound Speed [m/s]

5160

5180

5190

3600

Young Modulus [Pa]

2.08 1011

2.10 1011

0.69 1011

1.12 1011

      Sometimes for not obvious reasons attempt of creation of certain harmonic may not be succesful. For example in the case of the brass rod, instead of a first harmonic always a fifth harmonic was created.
      Rods used for measurements must not be too small and their ends must be cut perpendicularly to their lengths. Otherwise there is not enough energy or its dissipation is too fast to make accurate measurements. As the supports narrow wooden blocks were used.

     How to make a simple amplifier for a Radio Shack microphone

      The microphone amplifier schematic is presented in Fig. 3. It shows how electronic components can be arranged on a half of a predrilled board. Specifications of the components are shown in the table below. The amplification of the input signal ranges from 100 to 1000 and depends on adjustment of the 100 K potentiometer. After the board is mounted with help of the machine screws and spacers on the bottom of the aluminum box, an additional hole securing access to the 100 K potentiometer must be drilled in the top of the box. The battery holder, switch and input, output jacks should be mounted on the sides of the bottom part of the box.

Fig. 3.   Schematic of microphone amplifier

The list  of parts

Item

Quant.

Catalog #

Item

Quant.

Catalog #

Resistors 3.3K

2

271-1328 Screws, machine

5

64-3010
Resistors 10K

1

271-1335 Spacers

4

64-3024
Resistors 47K

4

271-1342 Connector, battery

1

270-325
Resistors 100K

1

271-1347 Holder, battery

1

270-326
Capacitors 0.47u

3

272-1433 Battery, 9V

1

23-553
Op Amp 1458

1

276-038 Switch, STSP

1

275-645
IC socket

1

276-1995 Jack 1/8''

1

274-251
Board, predrilled

1

276-148 Microphone, omni

1

33-1052
Box, metal

1

270-239  Wire #30

 1

 278-501,2,3

Search PSIgate, the physical sciences information gateway

for physical sciences subjects

PSIgate

Led by the PSIgate team at the University of Manchester, PSIgate is a free online catalogue of high quality Internet resources in the physical sciences. Resources are selected, catalogued and indexed by researchers and other specialists in their respective fields.